TV Review: The Walking Dead – Secrets

The barn full of zombies remains filled with zombies, Sophia remains missing, and the specter of getting kicked off the farm is still hovering over Rick’s head, but in the penultimate episode before the mid-season break, it feels like a lot is happening. Sure, it helps that there were two zombie encounters this week, one of which being a large scale set piece in a creepy, abandon suburb, but there was a lot of other moving parts to Secrets that made it work.

Pretend these colorful bottles are zombies.

The titular secrets, were, of course, the big ones. For whatever reason, poor Glenn has been entrusted with all those secrets, and he is ill equipped to handle them. With Lori’s pregnancy, he is quite concerned about his knowing while Rick is ignorant, and this is indeed and awkward position to be in. I really like the way Glenn chooses to deal with this as well: he offers to help in any way he can, even accepting relatively dangerous missions into town to gather supplies, all the while bugging her to tell her husband. This seemed to really hit Glenn’s natural character rhythms well.

What also worked for me was his suddenly vomiting out both Lori’s pregnancy and the barn of the living dead to Dale, after minimal prompting. Glenn is doing his best juggling these issues, but he’s go no stomach for politics and the secrets that go along with them. So what does he do? He goes to the oldest, most centered member of the group and dumps the whole thing in his lap. Perhaps not the best way to handle the situation, but pretty much what I would expect him to do.

On the other hand, it seemed like there were far, far too many scenes of him walking around, hovering, and generally looking awkward and suspicious at the beginning of the episode. I get what they were doing, but the audience isn’t stupid; there was no need to lay it on so thick. Thankfully, that nonsense was kept to the first act.

Those secrets led to a number of confrontations, the best being the low simmering one between Dale and Hershel. I really liked this scene for one important reason: the whole time Dale was trying to look Hershel in the face, while Hershel lectured on and on while never once making eye contact with the other man. I thought this was really telling. Dale and Maggie’s scenes were fairly well done, although Maggie’s blowing up at Lori was a bit much, especially since she and Glenn would have had the whole way back to the farm to talk and hopefully decompress a bit. Of course that did also lead to a really nice scene with the two discussing Glenn’s role in the group and how much Maggie hated it. I was happy to see Glenn reinforcing that position just a little while later when he talked to Lori; again pushing her to talk to Rick.

Speaking of talking to Rick, that decision was taken out of her hands. After choking down a whole pile of Plan B, she realizes she can’t go through with it and runs off to vomit them all out. Rick, of course, wanders in and finds all the packaging just sitting there. So he confront Lori and out pops not only the pregnancy, but Lori’s affair with Shane. I have to say, I didn’t see that coming. Rick’s reaction to the latter was bizarre, but pretty much in character. I can’t say I’d be so calm, but I guess she was telling something that he already knew and had come to peace with.

The first half of their discussion, however, was about abortion. This is the second time the show had broached the subject, and this time much less obliquely. I don’t want to turn this into a political discussion, and I’m not going to go into my personal beliefs here, but I have to say I found it a bit unbelievable that Lori was the only one who was seriously weighing having a baby in this kind of world and figuring out whether that was something she could do, and something she could put on that baby, who didn’t have any choice in the situation.

And then there was Shane. This week he didn’t interact much with Rick, and stuck primarily with Dale and Andrea. It was nice seeing him break away from his normal pairings, especially given the standoff with Dale, which was the episode’s best moment. I also loved that the whole thing was triggered by the sexual tension between Andrea and Shane finally coming to a head. Yeah, Dale can claim he’s looking out for Andrea all day and night, but it’s always more interesting when there are ulterior motives behind his actions.

Secrets was a pretty solid episode, and a great lead in to the mid-season finale. There were some clunker moments, but on the whole it was a great hour of TV. The suburb full of zombies definitely helps.

Grade: B

27 Comments

Calicade

Couldn’t hit a damn moving log 5-10 yards away?.. Hell it would be reasonable if she was shooting at the knot… But no she was aiming at the whole damn log and couldn’t hit it.

Reply
Dave

Yeah, that was kind of pathetic. With a target that size at that kind of distance I could hit it every time, and I’m not a very good shot.

Reply
Dave

Apologies for not being online to kick off the conversation yesterday evening. I was just completely beat after the weekend and wanted to just concentrate on the show.

Reply
angelina

I LOVED this episode. I love them all but I think the stories keep getting better. I should have seen Andrea/Shane coming (giggle) over the last few episodes but I didn’t. I guess I was focused on Lori/Shane instead.

I am sooooooo glad Lori was finally busted. I’m not sure which way Rick would go about getting rid of the baby but I was glad he was mad that she wasn’t letting him share the desicion. I think she finally got some of what she gives. She has been such a cold bitch. It’s nice to see her soften up for a change.

I do like how Glenn reacted this week too. He is young and is trying to manage women in a way that I am sure he did not do before – Lori put him in a terrible spot and Maggie is a bit wackko with grief.

My guess is that Shane finally bites the dust next episode. I was really Team Shane at the end of last season but I’ve really grown to dislike him. Not hate yet… I save that for Merle.

Reply
Dave

I’m pretty sympathetic to Shane as well. Outside of his attacking Lori at the CDC, which I thought was way outside of what his character would do, most everything he’s done has been coldly defensible, if you’re twisted enough. I think he ads something to the show.

I do think you’re right about him dying soon. I’m not sure about the next episode, but I can’t see him surviving the season.

Reply
angelina

I am confused about how Andrea will react when he does bite the dust. Will she sink back into the funk or realize that he was out of control and had to go?

Reply
Dave

That should be interesting. I’m hoping she doesn’t go into another funk, because we’ve had enough of that.

angelina

Almost forgot: kudos for the the scene where Dale confronts Hershel. I think the dialoge was almost verbatum from the comic. “Paranoid schizophrenics are dangerous but we don’t shoot them.”

Reply
Dave

Dale got some awesome scenes this week. He’s probably the strongest actor in the cast, so it’s always nice to see him do something other than being the sage old man.

Reply
angelina

When I took the “Which Character are You” quiz. I got Dale so I always like his scenes. He is definatetly the voice of reason.
I did think it was odd that Maggie says that Hershel is angry with her about the barn when Dale says he found out about that on his own.
Hershel should not know Dale well enough to know he is covering for someone.

Reply
Dave

I thought that was odd too. I wonder if Hershel was mad that they found out, and Maggie is just extrapolating.

But didn’t she say that he was mad at her? That makes less sense.

Zombiemutts

Guessing it had to do with all the budget and staffing changes. It won’t hurt the ratings one fraction of a point tho. HBO has proven that but yeah momentum takes a dive.

Reply
angelina

The major networks do that to make room for holiday shows. I was thinking that they were doing the same.

Bring on the Christmas Movies!!!

Zombiemutts

And the more I think about it, the more I agree with your comment about wasting the CDC story line, Dave.

Blown opportunity.

Reply
Dave

I don’t think the writers had any idea what they were doing and just said, “Well they’re in Atlanta, let’s send them to the CDC.”

Reply
angelina

I was thinking about that this morning. I was sure that the guy told Rick Lori was prego. I wonder if they’ll come back to that.

Open story lines:
1) Where’s Merle?
2) Where’s Morgan?
3) Where’s Sophia?

Missing anything?

Reply
Dave

4. Is Daryl going to go coocoo bananas on Rick?
5. Barn full of zombies, something is going to go wrong there
6. Is Hershel going to force them to leave?
7. Is Shane going to go coocoo bananas on Rick (or anyone else for that matter)?

Reply
angelina

My bad… I was thinking cliff-hangers that may not get resloved. I think we’ll see a resolution to Daryl and Shane and Hershel and his barn.

zombiemutts

I have a half-baked theory that people will GENERALLY prefer whatever they come across first, the comics or the TV show. I have everything up to issue #79…going to start reading. We’ll see I guess.

I am already up to issue 5.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *